Get certified

Habit books

Tiny Habits vs. Atomic Habits: what's the difference?

Short answer

Both books say to start small. Atomic Habits (James Clear, 2018) shapes a cue-craving-response-reward loop with four laws and puts identity at the core. Tiny Habits (BJ Fogg, 2019) uses B=MAP and a recipe that ends in celebration, because Fogg teaches that emotions create habits. The two methods work well together.

I should tell you up front where I stand. Dr. BJ Fogg is my brother, and I've run Tiny Habits Academy since 2012. I've tried to describe Atomic Habits the way James Clear does, in his own words and with links to his writing, so you can check it for yourself.

What is Tiny Habits?

Tiny Habits is a method for building habits, created by Dr. BJ Fogg, who founded the Behavior Design Lab at Stanford University. He started sharing it in 2011 and published the full system in Tiny Habits: The Small Changes That Change Everything (Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, December 31, 2019).

The method rests on the Fogg Behavior Model, which BJ first published in a 2009 paper (Fogg, 2009). It says a behavior happens when Motivation, Ability and a Prompt come together at the same moment: B=MAP. Because motivation rises and falls, Tiny Habits works on the other two. You make the behavior tiny so your ability is high, and you attach it to a routine you already do so the prompt is reliable.

Every Tiny Habits recipe has three parts, which BJ calls the ABCs:

  • Anchor: an existing routine, like brushing your teeth.
  • Behavior: a tiny version of the new habit, something you do at least once a day that takes less than 30 seconds and little effort (Tiny Habits, Welcome).
  • Celebration: something you do right away to create a positive feeling, like a smile or saying "Victory!"

A recipe reads, "After I brush, I will floss one tooth," and then you celebrate. Our guide to the Fogg Behavior Model explains B=MAP in detail.

What is Atomic Habits?

Atomic Habits is a book by James Clear, published by Avery, an imprint of Penguin Random House, on October 16, 2018 (Penguin Random House). Its full subtitle is An Easy & Proven Way to Build Good Habits & Break Bad Ones.

Clear breaks every habit into four steps: cue, craving, response and reward. "The cue triggers a craving, which motivates a response, which provides a reward, which satisfies the craving and, ultimately, becomes associated with the cue," he writes. He credits Charles Duhigg's The Power of Habit and Nir Eyal's Hooked with shaping this picture of the habit loop (Clear, How to start new habits).

From that loop he builds the Four Laws of Behavior Change (Atomic Habits summary):

  1. Make it obvious (cue).
  2. Make it attractive (craving).
  3. Make it easy (response).
  4. Make it satisfying (reward).

To break a bad habit, you turn them around: make it invisible, unattractive, difficult and unsatisfying. Clear is careful not to oversell his framework. "It would be irresponsible for me to claim that these four laws are an exhaustive framework for changing any human behavior," he writes, "but I think they're close."

Two other ideas show up all through the book. One is compounding: "if you can get 1 percent better each day for one year, you'll end up thirty-seven times better by the time you're done." The other is identity, which I'll come back to below.

How do the core models compare?

BJ's model explains whether a single behavior happens at a given moment. Clear's loop explains how a behavior repeats over time. The two overlap more than their different vocabulary suggests.

Look at how Clear describes the response step: "Whether a response occurs depends on how motivated you are and how much friction is associated with the behavior," and "your response also depends on your ability." Motivation and ability are two of the three elements in B=MAP. Clear's cue does the same job as BJ's prompt, and his law "make it easy" matches BJ's focus on ability.

The biggest structural difference is the craving step. Clear gives craving its own stage, with its own law (make it attractive) and its own tactics. BJ treats motivation as the least reliable lever. He says to design for ability and prompts first, and to check motivation last when a habit isn't working.

How small is small in each book?

Both books shrink the starting behavior, and then they handle it differently over time.

Clear's Two-Minute Rule says, "When you start a new habit, it should take less than two minutes to do." So "Read before bed each night" becomes "Read one page." He calls the two-minute version a "gateway habit" and says "you have to standardize before you can optimize" (Clear, the 2-Minute Rule). For Clear, the small start is a way into a larger routine.

BJ's limit is tighter, under 30 seconds, and he asks you to keep it there. "Set the bar low, keep it low, overachieve whenever you feel like it, but don't raise the bar," he said in a 2022 interview (Osmosis). If you floss every tooth one night, the extra teeth are a bonus. Tomorrow you're still only committing to one tooth.

Emotion or identity: what makes a habit stick?

This is where the two books differ most in emphasis, though each author touches on both ideas.

For Clear, identity is the deepest of three layers of change: outcomes, processes and identity. "The key to building lasting habits is focusing on creating a new identity first," he writes (Clear, Identity-based habits). Small actions prove the new identity to yourself: "Every action you take is a vote for the type of person you wish to become" (Clear, quotes). Clear uses feelings too. His fourth law, make it satisfying, rests on rewards, and he writes that "feelings of pleasure and disappointment are part of the feedback mechanism" that helps the brain sort useful actions from useless ones.

For BJ, emotion comes first. "When I teach people about human behavior, I boil it down to three words: Emotions create habits. Not repetition. Not frequency. Not fairy dust. Emotions" (Fogg, TED Ideas, 2020). That's why celebration is a required step in every recipe, done right after the behavior, and not an extra reward you add when you can. He calls the feeling of success Shine.

BJ sees identity as something that follows. "When you feel successful doing something tiny, that's what changes your identity," he said (Osmosis, 2022). Flossing one tooth and feeling good about it can grow into "I'm the kind of person who takes care of my teeth."

Did Atomic Habits borrow habit stacking from Tiny Habits?

Clear gives BJ the credit. In his writing on habit stacking, he calls it "a special form of an implementation intention" and says the method "was created by BJ Fogg as part of his Tiny Habits program" (Clear, Habit stacking). His formula is "After/Before [current habit], I will [new habit]."

The Tiny Habits recipe uses the same "After I..." structure. It adds two rules that habit stacking doesn't require: keep the new behavior tiny, and celebrate right after it. Our guide on habit stacking vs. Tiny Habits anchors covers the history and how to pick a strong anchor.

Tiny Habits vs. Atomic Habits: side-by-side comparison

Tiny HabitsAtomic Habits
AuthorDr. BJ Fogg, founder of the Behavior Design Lab at StanfordJames Clear, writer
PublishedDecember 31, 2019 (Houghton Mifflin Harcourt)October 16, 2018 (Avery)
Core modelFogg Behavior Model: B=MAP (Motivation, Ability, Prompt)Habit loop: cue, craving, response, reward
Practical frameworkThe ABC recipe: Anchor, tiny Behavior, CelebrationFour Laws: obvious, attractive, easy, satisfying
Starting sizeUnder 30 seconds, little effortUnder two minutes (Two-Minute Rule)
Over timeKeep the bar low; do extra when you feel like itStandardize first, then optimize; aim to get 1% better
What wires the habit inPositive emotion right after the behavior ("emotions create habits")Immediate satisfaction from the reward (fourth law)
Role of identityGrows from feeling successful at tiny behaviorsThe deepest layer; each action is a "vote" for who you want to be
CueAnchor: an existing routine, chosen by location, frequency and trailing edgeAny obvious cue; habit stacking is one tool, credited to Fogg
Breaking bad habitsRemove the prompt, make it harder, then address motivation; swap in a new habit if neededMake it invisible, unattractive, difficult, unsatisfying

Which should you use?

It depends on where your habits break down.

If you keep forgetting, the cue is the problem, and both books can help. A Tiny Habits anchor tied to a specific trailing edge, like "after I start the dishwasher," gives you a precise cue.

If you remember but skip it, the behavior is too hard for that moment. Both books tell you to shrink it. Tiny Habits goes smaller and keeps it small, which helps on low-energy days.

If a habit lasts a week and then fades, pay attention to how it feels. This is where Tiny Habits differs most. Add a celebration right after the behavior, and keep trying until you find one that gives you a real feeling of success.

If you think in goals and systems, or you want one framework for both building and breaking habits, Clear's four laws make an easy checklist to remember.

If you coach other people, Tiny Habits gives you an order to follow with clients: check the prompt, then ability, then motivation. That keeps the conversation on design instead of willpower.

Can you use Tiny Habits and Atomic Habits together?

Yes. The methods don't contradict each other, and Clear credits BJ for one of his core techniques.

Here's one way to combine them. Decide on the identity you want, in Clear's terms. Then build the first habits for it with Tiny Habits recipes: a precise anchor, a behavior under 30 seconds, and a celebration right after. Use Clear's four laws as a checklist when you set up your environment, and use B=MAP to troubleshoot any habit that stalls.

For coaches: talking about both books with clients

Some of your clients will already have read Atomic Habits, and there's no need to argue with it. Ask which ideas they've tried and where the habit broke down. Then map it to B=MAP: Was there a prompt? Was it easy enough? Did they want to do it?

The piece clients most often haven't tried is celebration, and adults find it awkward at first. The Tiny Habits Coach Certification trains coaches to diagnose stalled habits with B=MAP and to coach celebration with clients.

Try Tiny Habits for five days

The fastest way to feel the difference is to practice the method. The free 5-day Tiny Habits program takes about 25 minutes to set up over a weekend, then about 3 minutes a day, Monday to Friday. A certified Tiny Habits coach checks in with you each afternoon.

Start the free 5-day program

Frequently asked questions

Is Tiny Habits or Atomic Habits better?

Neither one is better for everyone. Atomic Habits gives you a broad framework, the Four Laws, built on a cue-craving-response-reward loop. Tiny Habits gives you a specific recipe built on the Fogg Behavior Model, with tiny behaviors and celebration. Choose based on where your habits break down, or use both.

What is the main difference between Tiny Habits and Atomic Habits?

The main difference is what each one says wires a habit in. BJ Fogg teaches that emotions create habits, so every Tiny Habits recipe ends with a celebration. James Clear puts identity at the core, with each small action as a vote for the person you want to be.

Which came first, Tiny Habits or Atomic Habits?

The Tiny Habits method came first. BJ Fogg began sharing it in 2011, and he published the Fogg Behavior Model in 2009. The books came out in the other order: Atomic Habits was published October 16, 2018, and Tiny Habits on December 31, 2019.

Did James Clear get habit stacking from BJ Fogg?

James Clear writes that habit stacking "was created by BJ Fogg as part of his Tiny Habits program." Tiny Habits uses the same "After I..." structure and adds a tiny behavior and an immediate celebration.

Is the Two-Minute Rule the same as a tiny habit?

They're close. Clear's Two-Minute Rule says a new habit should take less than two minutes to start. A Tiny Habit takes less than 30 seconds, and BJ asks you to keep that low bar instead of raising it, while doing more whenever you feel like it.

Can I use both methods at once?

Yes, they work together. You can use Clear's identity framing and four laws to set your direction, and Tiny Habits recipes to make each new behavior small, well anchored and celebrated.

Sources

  1. Fogg, B.J. (2019). Tiny Habits: The Small Changes That Change Everything. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. Publication date: Google Books. (Source for the ABC recipe, Shine and the trailing edge.)
  2. Fogg, B.J. (2009). A behavior model for persuasive design. Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Persuasive Technology, Article 40. ACM. doi.org/10.1145/1541948.1541999
  3. Fogg, B.J. Welcome to Tiny Habits. tinyhabits.com/welcome
  4. Fogg, B.J. (2020, January 6). How you can use the power of celebration to make new habits stick. TED Ideas. ideas.ted.com/how-you-can-use-the-power-of-celebration-to-make-new-habits-stick
  5. Osmosis (2022, March 10). One key to behavior change? Set the bar low and keep it there: Dr. BJ Fogg [podcast transcript]. osmosis.org/podcast/behavior-change-through-tiny-habits-dr-bj-fogg
  6. Clear, J. (2018). Atomic Habits: An Easy & Proven Way to Build Good Habits & Break Bad Ones. Avery. penguinrandomhouse.com/books/543993/atomic-habits-by-james-clear
  7. Clear, J. Atomic Habits summary. jamesclear.com/atomic-habits-summary (Four Laws, inversions, 1 percent better)
  8. Clear, J. How to start new habits that actually stick (excerpt, Chapter 3). jamesclear.com/three-steps-habit-change (habit loop, response and ability, credit to Duhigg and Eyal, "close" quote)
  9. Clear, J. Identity-based habits (excerpt). jamesclear.com/identity-based-habits
  10. Clear, J. "Every action you take is a vote for the type of person you wish to become." jamesclear.com/quotes/every-action-you-take-is-a-vote-for-the-type-of-person-you-wish-to-become
  11. Clear, J. How to stop procrastinating by using the "2-Minute Rule" (excerpt). jamesclear.com/how-to-stop-procrastinating
  12. Clear, J. Habit stacking: how to build new habits by taking advantage of old ones (excerpt). jamesclear.com/habit-stacking

Start tiny. Change everything.

Talk with Linda about whether certification fits your practice.