Get certified

Habit formation

Habit stacking vs. Tiny Habits anchors: what's the difference?

Short answer

Habit stacking and Tiny Habits anchors use the same core move: attach a new behavior to something you already do, as in "After I pour my coffee, I will…". Dr. BJ Fogg built this into his Tiny Habits method in 2011 and called the existing routine an anchor. The name "habit stacking" was popularized later by S.J. Scott and James Clear, and Tiny Habits adds two rules stacking doesn't require: make the new behavior tiny, and celebrate right after it.

What is habit stacking?

Habit stacking means linking a new habit to a habit you already have, so the old one reminds you to do the new one. The term reached a wide audience through two books.

S.J. Scott's Habit Stacking: 97 Small Life Changes That Take Five Minutes or Less (2014) uses the term for building a single daily routine, about 15 to 30 minutes long, made up of many small actions. You follow the routine from a checklist, so instead of tracking dozens of separate habits you track one routine.

James Clear's Atomic Habits (2018) uses the term the way most people use it today. His formula is: "After [current habit], I will [new habit]." He describes habit stacking as a special form of an implementation intention, which is a plan that links a behavior to a specific situation. Psychologist Peter Gollwitzer's research on implementation intentions found that if-then plans like these help people follow through on their goals.

Clear also suggests chaining stacks so each new habit cues the next one: pour coffee, then meditate for sixty seconds, then write your to-do list. In his writing on habit stacking, Clear says the method was created by BJ Fogg as part of the Tiny Habits program.

What is an anchor in Tiny Habits?

In the Tiny Habits method, an anchor is an existing routine, like brushing your teeth, or an event that happens, like a phone ringing. The anchor reminds you to do a new tiny behavior. Fogg picked the word because you attach the new habit to something stable and reliable in your day.

Every Tiny Habits recipe has three parts, which Fogg calls the ABCs:

  • Anchor moment: the routine you already do.
  • Behavior: a tiny version of the new habit, something that takes less than 30 seconds and little effort.
  • Celebration: something you do right away to create a positive feeling, like a fist pump or saying "Nice!"
After I start the coffee maker, I will open my journal. Then I'll smile and say "Good start."

In the language of the Fogg Behavior Model, the anchor is the prompt. Fogg describes three kinds of prompts: Person Prompts (something inside you), Context Prompts (something in your surroundings, like a sticky note or an app alert) and Action Prompts (a behavior you already do). Anchors are Action Prompts, and every Tiny Habits recipe uses one, because your existing routines already happen reliably.

Where did the idea come from?

Fogg began experimenting with his own habits in early 2011. He had already figured out two pieces: make the new behavior very small, and celebrate right after doing it. He was still missing a reliable reminder. Sticky notes wouldn't scale. One day, as he opened his sock drawer to get dressed, the answer came to him as one word: after. A new habit needs to come right after something you already do.

Fogg shared the method with friends in December 2011. About 60 people joined the first week, and it grew from there. Since then he has personally coached more than 60,000 people in the method, and he published the full system in his 2019 book Tiny Habits.

Here is the fair summary. Fogg created the "after" technique and named the routine an anchor. Scott and Clear brought the "habit stacking" name to a wide audience, and Clear explicitly credits Fogg. And the broader idea of tying a behavior to a situation has deep roots in implementation intentions research.

Habit stacking vs. anchors: how do they compare?

Habit stacking (Clear)Habit stacking (Scott)Tiny Habits anchor (Fogg)
SourceAtomic Habits, 2018Habit Stacking, 2014Tiny Habits method, 2011; book, 2019
Format"After [current habit], I will [new habit]."A checklist routine of many small actions"After I [anchor], I will [tiny behavior]." Then celebrate.
Size of new behaviorAny size. Clear's separate Two-Minute Rule says new habits should start at under two minutes.Small actions, each about five minutes or lessTiny by design: under 30 seconds, little effort
Role of emotionCovered by a separate law, "make it satisfying"Small, enjoyable rewards for finishing the routineBuilt into every recipe: celebrate right after the behavior
Choosing the cuePick a specific current habit with the same frequencyOne daily routine, followed from a checklistMatch location, frequency and theme; use the anchor's trailing edge
Underlying modelThe Four Laws of Behavior ChangeRoutine-building and checklistsFogg Behavior Model (B=MAP)

The biggest practical difference is what happens after the cue. A stack tells you what to do next. A Tiny Habits recipe also makes the behavior small enough to do on a bad day and adds a celebration to wire it in. Fogg's position is that emotions create habits, so every recipe includes a celebration.

Which one should you use?

Both rely on the same mechanism, so you don't have to pick a side. The useful question is where your habits tend to break down.

  • If you forget, the cue is the problem. Either approach helps, and a precise anchor helps most.
  • If you remember but skip it, the behavior is too hard for that moment. Shrink it until it takes under 30 seconds.
  • If you do it for a week and then fade, add a celebration. The feeling of success right after the behavior is what Tiny Habits uses to make it automatic.
  • If you already have reliable habits and want to build a longer routine, chaining one recipe after another works well. Get each link automatic before you add the next.

If you want to stop a habit rather than start one, see our guide on how to break a bad habit.

How do you write an anchor recipe that sticks?

Fogg's guidance on choosing anchors is specific, and it's the part most habit stacking advice leaves out.

  1. Match the physical location. In Fogg's experience, an anchor in one place and a new habit in another rarely works. If the habit happens in the kitchen, find a kitchen anchor. Location is the most important match.
  2. Match the frequency. For a once-a-day habit, use a once-a-day anchor. Fogg wanted push-ups throughout his day, so he anchored them to something he did several times a day: "After I pee, I will do two push-ups."
  3. Match the theme or purpose when you can. If your morning coffee is your quiet time, pair it with journaling, not with opening your inbox.
  4. Use the trailing edge. A fuzzy anchor like "after breakfast" or "when I feel stressed" doesn't work. Find the last action of the routine: "After I start the dishwasher" or "After I turn off the faucet."
  5. Make the behavior tiny. Floss one tooth. Read one paragraph. Put on your walking shoes.
  6. Celebrate right away. Pick a celebration that feels natural to you, and do it immediately after the behavior.

Fogg also describes two useful variations. A Meanwhile Habit fills a waiting period, like "After I turn on the shower, and while I wait for it to warm up, I will…". A Pearl Habit uses an annoyance as the anchor and turns it into something good, the way an oyster turns an irritant into a pearl.

To practice your first recipe with a certified coach checking in each day, join the free 5-day Tiny Habits program.

For coaches: helping clients choose anchors

Many clients arrive having tried habit stacking and say it "didn't work." Usually the cue was fuzzy, the new habit was in a different room, or the behavior was too big for a tired evening. Walking through location, frequency, theme and trailing edge with a client often fixes the recipe in a few minutes, and it teaches them to troubleshoot on their own.

Certified Tiny Habits coaches learn to spot weak anchors quickly and to coach the celebration, the step clients most often skip. If you already use habit stacking with clients, certification gives you the full method it came from.

Explore the certification

Frequently asked questions

Is habit stacking the same as Tiny Habits?

They share one technique: placing a new behavior right after an existing routine. Tiny Habits adds two more rules, starting with a very small version of the behavior and celebrating immediately afterward to create a feeling of success.

Who invented habit stacking?

The technique of attaching a new habit after an existing routine was created by BJ Fogg as part of his Tiny Habits program, which he began sharing in December 2011. James Clear credits Fogg in his writing on habit stacking. The name "habit stacking" was popularized by S.J. Scott's 2014 book and by Clear's 2018 book Atomic Habits.

What is an anchor habit?

In the Tiny Habits method, an anchor is an existing routine or event, such as brushing your teeth or a phone ringing, that reminds you to do a new tiny behavior. You write it as: "After I [anchor], I will [tiny behavior]."

What if my anchor isn't working?

Make the anchor more precise by using its trailing edge, the last action of the routine. For example, change "After I eat breakfast" to "After I start the dishwasher." Also check that the anchor happens in the same place and as often as the new habit.

Sources

  1. Fogg, B.J. (2019). Tiny Habits: The Small Changes That Change Everything. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt.
  2. Fogg, B.J. How I cracked the code for creating habits. ACE ProSource, Behavior Change Special Issue. acefitness.org
  3. Fogg, B.J. Welcome to Tiny Habits. tinyhabits.com
  4. Clear, J. (2018). Atomic Habits. Avery. Excerpt: Habit stacking: how to build new habits by taking advantage of old ones. jamesclear.com
  5. Scott, S.J. (2014). Habit Stacking: 97 Small Life Changes That Take Five Minutes or Less. CreateSpace.
  6. Gollwitzer, P.M. (1999). Implementation intentions: Strong effects of simple plans. American Psychologist, 54(7), 493–503.

Start tiny. Change everything.

Talk with Linda about whether certification fits your practice.